Welcome back to A Song For You. Summer may be dwindling, but I’m determined to stretch the season a little longer with a few more adventures.
Always eager to escape the all-too-familiar swamp-like humidity of summer in Washington, D.C., I ventured out to cool off wherever I could. The highlight of my summer was no doubt a long swim I took at Echo Lake in Maine’s breathtaking Acadia National Park.
Waist deep in the water with two of my closest friends, I looked back at kids playing catch and sunbathers basking in the late-afternoon sun on the beach behind me. Ahead of me lay more than 200 acres of open water. Without so much as a word to my buddies, I quietly started to swim out into the great wide open. Stopping to float on my back whenever I felt like it, I channeled Forrest Gump and decided to swim as far as I could until I didn’t feel like swimming anymore.
Having shut down my Garmin after our morning hikes, I have no idea how far I swam out. And I don’t really care. Strava be damned. But by the time I decided to turn back, I could hardly make out any of the beach umbrellas that littered my sandy starting point. No motorboats are allowed on the lake, so there was none of the noise that usually strips the tranquility from lakes this size. For a few minutes, I felt weightless, floating around with not a peep around me except for the faint laughs of some kids pushing each other off a distant dock.
I don’t know if I’ve ever been at peace with myself and my surroundings more than I was in that moment. By the time I returned to shore, that fleeting moment was already a memory. Already feeling nostalgic on my trip home, I asked Substack readers to share their favorite songs about bodies of water, hoping that some of the tracks mentioned would bring back that feeling.
Great songwriters have an uncanny ability to capture life’s sublime moments like this, and several of the songs shared did just the trick.
There’s still time to go chase down your version of this moment before Labor Day unceremoniously brings our summers to a close. Check out a few stories behind songs submitted by readers about different bodies of water below, and let the collaborative playlist including everyone’s submissions be the soundtrack to your road trip or cookout.
Lake: “Lake Marie” | John Prine
Bob Dylan has named this his favorite John Prine song, while to me that feels a bit like choosing a favorite child, I can certainly understand why. This song features three completely different stories braided into one.
Prine first heard about the real Lake Marie (technically “Lake Mary”) from a crew member while on tour in Wisconsin. Curious, he and his brother drove out to see it, then went to the library to dig up its history. What they found was local lore about two abandoned babies, Elizabeth and Marie, found in the woods generations ago and given their names to the two lakes nearby. Prine used that as his opening verse, before making a sharp departure into a second story about a marriage falling apart on a camping trip at the lake, and finally into a third story, based on grisly true-crime footage he remembered from childhood television.
Like many of Prine’s songs, this song’s narrative structure defies what I thought was possible in songwriting.
Creek: “Meet Me at the Creek” | Billy Strings
Billy Strings wrote this song about the Maple River in Muir, Michigan where he grew up.
Strings’ childhood there was marked by addiction and hardship in his family, and Turmoil & Tinfoil, the 2017 album that included this song, is full of tracks about drug addiction, incarceration, and grief.
When I hear “Meet Me at the Creek”, it reminds me of the water’s innate ability to put us at ease. Like the song’s narrator, sometimes we all just need to take time to sit by the water and let it carry our troubles off instead of running from them again.
Bay: “(Sittin’ On) The Dock of the Bay” | Otis Redding
Otis Redding wrote the first verse of this one on a houseboat at Waldo Point Harbor in Sausalito, California, in August 1967, staying there at the invitation of concert promoter Bill Graham after a run of shows at the Fillmore. He’d been listening obsessively to the Beatles’ just-released Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band and was looking to push his sound somewhere new. Watching the boats go in and out of the bay, he scribbled down “sittin’ in the mornin’ sun, I’ll be sittin’ when the evenin’ comes”.
He finished the song months later in Memphis with Stax guitarist Steve Cropper, who wrote most of the specific, autobiographical lines like “I left my home in Georgia, headed for the Frisco Bay” since, as Cropper put it, “Otis didn’t really write about himself, but I did.” Redding recorded the final version on December 7, 1967, ad-libbing a whistled melody at the end because he’d forgotten the closing line he meant to sing.
Three days later, his plane crashed into Lake Monona in Madison, Wisconsin, killing him at 26. Cropper mixed the finished track, adding the sound of gulls and waves per Redding’s request, while divers were still searching the lake for his body. Released the following January, it became the first posthumous No. 1 single in U.S. chart history.
Sea: “The Sea” | Sierra Ferrell
Sierra Ferrell was living out of her van in Port Townsend, Washington, when she wrote this cosmically-charged country tune. There’s also a name joke buried in the title: she’s said she wrote it in part because her own name is basically “Sea-erra.”
“The Sea” opens Long Time Coming, her 2021 label debut, with a woozy, minor-key sway built around Ferrell’s own musical saw: an eerie, seasick sound that turns the song into something closer to a haunted sea shanty than a straightforward love song. And it is, in its way, a love song: to the water, and to how easily its beauty tips into danger.
“If you find yourself goin’ under,” she sings, “you’ll remember the taste.”
Ocean: “The Ocean” | Led Zeppelin
Okay, this song isn’t actually about a body of water at all. But I’m still counting it.
According to the band’s biographer Dave Lewis, the ocean is a metaphor for the “sea of heads” Robert Plant faced in the auditoriums — a nod to the massive crowds Zeppelin was playing to by the time Houses of the Holy was released in 1973.
Musically, this song is something of a magic trick that’s always captured my imagination. It runs on an unusual septuple meter, with a repeated two-measure phrase made up of one bar of 4/4 and one bar of 7/8, which is part of why the riff feels like it’s lurching in a way that somehow still grooves. For me, I’ve always thought this unique rhythm reflected the uneven nature of waves crashing into shore.
After four minutes of that stomping riff, the song swerves into a completely unrelated fifties-style doo-wop breakdown, with John Bonham and John Paul Jones singing backing vocals. Buried in that closing section is the sweetest detail on the whole track: the “girl who won my heart” is Robert Plant’s daughter Carmen, who was three years old at the time of recording.
I’ll always sing along when Plant blurts out, unscripted and clearly delighted, “Oh, so good!” during the song’s triumphant apex.
River: “Brokedown Palace” | Grateful Dead
We’re now eight months into A Song For You, and this is somehow the first time we’re featuring a song by my favorite band, the Grateful Dead. No better song encapsulates how I felt at Echo Lake than American Beauty’s “Brokedown Palace”.
Robert Hunter wrote the lyrics to “Brokedown Palace” in London in 1970, during a single, almost unbelievable afternoon at a friend’s flat that also produced “Ripple” and “To Lay Me Down” — three of the most beautiful songs in the Grateful Dead’s catalog.
Hunter later described the session as a kind of creative flood he had no control of.
“I sat there with a case of retsina and I opened up a bottle of that stuff, and for some reason this creative energy started racing through me and I could do no wrong.”
Jerry Garcia set the words to a gentle, gospel-tinged melody, and the finished song became a farewell in the most literal sense — my all-time favorite encore to Grateful Dead concerts.
For years, it closed out shows, with the river standing in for whatever finally carries you home.
“Listen to the river sing sweet songs, to rock my soul.”
Want more thematic playlists curated with the help of music listeners on Substack? Let me know what theme we should check out next in the comments.




Atlantis by Donovan?
Take to the River…both the Al Green and Talking Heads versions.
I have an abandoned house I visit deep in the woods on Martha’s Vineyard which I call the brokedown palace. Its proximity to the ocean on three sides likely contributed to its rapid dilapidation. One of the coolest spots I’ve found on the island. A grand old secret. It’s rare for anything to sit abandoned here these days… with soaring property values. But I think this one is deemed tribal land so it’s more complicated to sell or transfer.