Greetings from the Bowery Hotel in the East Village. It’s the night before Halloween and I’m really starting to feel the spooky vibes as I sink back into a velvet armchair in the hotel’s Gothic-inspired lounge.
I ducked in after an unseasonably warm October day, but now find myself sitting next to a crackling fireplace for the first time this fall. A Velvet Underground song just came on shuffle and my only concern is how many pints of Guinness I can fit into my budget. Okay, and whether the guy dressed as Slash at the table next to me might actually be Slash. This doesn't suck.
I've only been a resident for a short while, but man do I love this city.
I asked A Song For You's readers to share their favorite songs about the Big Apple, and you all gave me the soundtrack to the first chapter of my time here. I've had the playlist buzzing through my AirPods every time I've left my apartment since we made it. The songs picked paint the picture of why people come here, what we put up with to stay, and why leaving never crosses our minds.
Check out the full playlist of reader-selected songs:
Here's how one Virginia kid finally made it to the big city, through seven of your songs.
"Does This Bus Stop at 82nd Street?" by Bruce Springsteen
While Springsteen didn't have far to go to get here, I've taken the train from Asbury Park to Manhattan, and it still feels like stepping into another world. This song is a real sleeper pick from his 1973 debut, Greetings from Asbury Park, N.J. One for the real Bruce heads. The words tumble over each other like he's afraid someone will cut him off mid-sentence, and I always found it endearing how he was not-so-discreetly attempting to emulate another famed songwriter who once spent some time in New York City. I used to drive around listening to it, wondering what my life would look like if I ever left the friendly confines of where I grew up.
"Mona Lisas and Mad Hatters" by Elton John
Moving here felt a little like Alice going down the rabbit hole, so a song full of Mad Hatters seems right. Elton's lyricist Bernie Taupin wrote it after his first visit from England in 1970, when a gun went off near his hotel window. He heard a city that could scare you and dazzle you on the same block, and both are on full display throughout the song. These city lights sure shine bright, but everyone you pass seems to have a story about how (and why) they got here.
"Spanish Harlem" by Aretha Franklin
Taupin’s song was partly inspired by Ben E. King's "Spanish Harlem," which is convenient, because that's where I landed. After a chaotic apartment hunt, I found a place where the Upper East Side gives way to East Harlem. Jerry Leiber and Phil Spector wrote the song, and King made it a hit around 1960. The song’s story is a love letter to one flower growing out of the neighborhood's concrete. My favorite version is no doubt when Aretha cut it in 1971 and turned it into a sermon. East Harlem has been a center of the city's Latin music for generations, and you can feel that history everywhere you go. I’m also still dreaming about the life-altering burrito I had for dinner last night at my local taqueria.
"Shattered" by The Rolling Stones
Mick Jagger wrote this in the late '70s, when New York was broke, dirty, and daring you to move here anyway. He was living in the city then, and he half-speaks, half-sneers a litany of lyrics about rats, money, and sex over a groove borrowed from the punk and disco clubs downtown. The city has been scrubbed up since, but the hustle never left. You catch it on a packed sidewalk, in the scramble at the turnstiles, or when you find yourself side-stepping tourists who don’t realize we all clearly have somewhere to be… and that we’re probably already late.
"Romeo Had Juliette" by Lou Reed
There’s no hiding my lifelong adoration for my birthday twin, Lou Reed. People in my generation seem to gravitate almost exclusively to his early work with the Velvet Underground, but I’ve always been partial to his solo catalog. Stopping after his ’60s output feels like only watching the Godfather Part I.
By the time he put out New York in 1989, he'd been writing about this city's strangest residents for more than two decades. This song opens the album, which he wanted people to hear front to back, like a film. It stars Romeo Rodriguez and Juliette Bell, Shakespeare's lovers reborn on the street. As I get settled in, I find myself starting to collect characters of my own.
"Manhattan" by Blossom Dearie
At some point, the city stops being a show and becomes a place. I've found my coffee shops, made a few friends, and treasure my daily runs through Central Park. Richard Rodgers and Larry Hart wrote it in 1925 for a revue called The Garrick Gaieties, and it was their first big hit. It's about a couple with no money who find the city's cheap pleasures plenty. In my favorite version, Blossom Dearie sings it in a tiny, almost whispered voice, so it sounds less like a performance and more like someone telling you all the secrets you need to know about the city.
"Downtown Train" by Tom Waits
This city is a never-ending mystery. Every time you walk out your door, you never know who or what you'll see around the next turn. While Waits hails from the west coast, this song comes from Rain Dogs (1985), a New York album full of clanging junkyard percussion, with Keith Richards among its guests. There's a reason people have been writing songs about this city for more than a century. It always feels like something is about to happen.
Alright, my beer money is all gone and it’s still a bit too warm to spend the whole night sitting by the fire, so I'm heading home. Tomorrow I'll get up, catch a downtown train of my own, and let the day take me wherever it wants to go. Just how I like it.




What a great setup for beginning your New York venture and article. All the best to you as the journey unfolds!
Great choices. I loved Shattered because it captures the essence of NYC in the 70s. If you’ve seen Taxi Driver, The Warriors, or Escape from New York you know what I mean.