Welcome back to A Song For You — a weekly series of conversations with artists and music lovers about one song that holds a special meaning to them.
Each post dives into one song that left an indelible mark on their life through three parts:
The Journey Behind the Music: I set the scene to explore the song’s history, cultural impact, and the story of how it came to be.
In Their Own Words: Our guest reflects on their chosen song, sharing the personal story behind why it matters to them.
A Song For You: A carefully chosen recording or performance of the song, selected by the artist.
This week we’re joined by singer-songwriter Emma Derhak, who’s currently on the road with progressive rock jamband moe. and Boston-based psychedelic rock outfit The Chops. Her Song For You is “Reelin” in the Years” by Steely Dan.
The Journey Behind the Music: Sammy’s Thought Bubble
Every time I listen to Steely Dan (which anyone who knows me can testify, is often), I’m struck by how fully formed everything feels — every instrumental part, every vocal line, every production choice. Like it always existed, and someone just had the good fortune to find them.
I’ve always imagined Donald Fagen and Walter Becker crafting songs in a studio like mad chemists in a lab, in pursuit of their next great discovery.
But when the duo wrote “Reelin’ in the Years” in 1972, a last-minute call to an old friend ended up defining the track.
It’s a sardonic breakup kiss-off wrapped inside a shuffle groove so irresistible it practically dares you to feel sad. From Steely Dan’s debut album Can’t Buy a Thrill, it remains among the most perfectly constructed rock songs ever committed to tape. But the whimsical verses and catchy chorus are merely appetizers for Elliott Randall’s guitar solo.
Randall wasn’t even supposed to be there. He was called in as a session player — an old contact from Becker and Fagen’s days backing Jay and the Americans — because the band couldn’t crack the guitar part. He showed up to find no amp in the studio, plugged his ’63 Stratocaster into a bass amp someone had lying around, and played the entire thing start to finish in one unbroken take. Improvised, unrehearsed, no direction given. Then the engineer — thinking it was a warm-up — forgot to hit record.
So Randall did it again. That second take is the one we all know. Jimmy Page later called it his favorite guitar solo of all time and rated it 12 out of 10. Fagen’s verdict, characteristically, was “dumb but effective.”
Think about that for a minute. One of the greatest guitar performances in rock history only exists because someone had to step back up and do it again with the pressure ratcheted up, the tape finally rolling, and nothing but nerve and instinct to rely on. The song itself is about looking back with hard-won clarity, the narrator taking stock of what was wasted and what wasn’t. Fitting, then, that its most iconic moment was born from exactly that kind of pressure.
Our guest this week, Emma Derhak, knows something about that.
In Their Own Words: Emma Derhak on Reelin’ in the Years by Steely Dan
Growing up as Rob Derhak’s daughter — bassist, vocalist, and co-founder of moe. — I don’t remember a time where I felt like I was going to do anything else. I was at my first show when I was six months old — my dad took me out on stage in a baby carrier, and apparently I was just so calm up there, completely at peace. There are pictures of it somewhere. I’ve always just loved the scene. These are my people. I’m sticking around.

Every New Year’s Eve moe. concert, the kids would come up on stage and play their instruments with the band. But I was the youngest, so I was always just watching and jealous for a very long time. I couldn’t play an instrument proficiently — my ADHD meant I couldn’t do the same thing for longer than twenty or thirty minutes, and I’m still that way to this day.
So I waited.
When I was 14, they finally let me go on stage on New Year’s Eve. It was the Kodak Center in Rochester, New York, and my dad chose the Steely Dan classic “Reelin’ in the Years.” I practiced it the entire drive up — I made my parents play it on repeat in the car, and then in the hotel too. The day of the show I was shitting myself. I wouldn’t talk to people. I was probably being kind of difficult, honestly, because I knew there was going to be video online afterward and I had to do good. I had to make myself proud, make my dad proud. He was giving me something that only like one percent of kids ever get the opportunity to do. I better make it worth it.
That song was a real full circle moment for us, because Steely Dan was what we always listened to on road trips growing up. Me, my dad, and my brother Eddie agreed on a couple things growing up about music, and one of them was Can’t Buy a Thrill. On drives, they were the older ones in the front seat, so it was their choice. We were always listening to that album specifically.
I didn’t really get how incredible Can’t Buy a Thrill was, musically and production-wise, until a couple years ago when I started really diving into what I liked in music. Now I listen to it and I’m like, these guys were perfectionists. This is insane. I’m more of a feeling-based person when it comes to music. Whatever gets me moving, or thinking, or just feeling — that’s how I know I like it. I don’t really know why until I’ve listened to it a million times.
Even though I’d heard it countless times, my head was spinning when sound check came around. I practiced it once and I was in my head voice. It was just not what the song should sound like, at least coming from a 14-year-old girl. Chuck Garvey, moe.‘s guitarist, looked at me and said: get right up to the mic and sing as loud as you can. Stop being shy. You’re not shy. I had no idea I was supposed to do that. I did it, and it sounded great for where I was at 14. It just took one bit of advice, and Chuck knew how to get to me.
It being New Year’s Eve, they put me right at the ball drop at the peak of the set. I was sitting backstage alone and I didn’t want anyone to talk to me — just practicing, chugging water, and shaking. Finally my mom came back and got me, walked me up to the side stage. I watched the clock count down, and got the call up.
What I didn’t know was that my brother Zach had a plan. He knew I was going to be nervous, so he had somehow acquired a monkey mascot suit, and he had his Heelys on. Right after the first verse, he just heelied out onto the stage in the monkey suit and completely fell.
Me and my dad just started laughing, and after that I was like, fuck it, this is so fun. A lot of my nerves went away. My family knows me better than I know myself sometimes. The things they do — I think back on it now and I’m just like, how lucky am I that these people do crazy stuff just to make me feel better?
For a long time after that — up until I joined my first real band — I could not listen back to that show. I was so hard on myself, mostly because I was inspired by Aretha Franklin and Nina Simone, women with these incredibly mature voices that no child is going to have. I was just comparing myself to people I had no business comparing myself to. But now that I’m older, I look back at younger me and I’m just so happy for her. She did great for where she was. One thing I wish I’d done was be nicer to myself about it.
Now I’m on the road with both my own band The Chops and moe. — frequently sitting in to sing some of my all-time favorite songs. Every day there’s another weird little full-circle moment, and I’m constantly left wondering: how the hell is this real life? I just had lunch with my dad and Chuck — and it’s so nice to have that relationship still, as a 21-year-old girl having lunch with her dad and his best friend. Such a weird sentence to say. No one really does that. But they impacted me from such a young age, and they showed me what real friendship looks like.
It’s weird how you can be on the road and feel so at home. But that’s exactly what it is. I’m with my family, wherever we go.
A Song For You: “Reelin’ in the Year” performed by moe.
Watch Emma perform “Reelin’ in the Years” with moe. at the Kodak Center in Rochester, New York, on New Year’s Eve 2018.








So so sweet to watch/hear 14 year-old Emma in the video! So happy she shared this. And of course I never tire from hearing that
guitar solo as well! Amazing writing as usual—I look forward to your episodes every Sunday
Awesome as always!!!