What a summer this has been in the world of sports.
It started in May with Golden Tempo clawing his way from the back of the pack to become the Kentucky Derby winner, making Cherie DeVaux the first female trainer to win the run for the roses.
Then my beloved New York Knicks overcame multiple seemingly insurmountable deficits — culminating with the greatest moment in New York sports history when OG Anunoby’s immortal tip-in erased a 29-point deficit in Game 4 of the NBA Finals to deliver the city its first championship since 1973.
It was capped off by a tremendously exciting World Cup that saw Lionel Messi, almost certainly playing in the tournament for the final time, willing Argentina through each round only to watch it slip away in extra time in the championship match, falling 1-0 to an infallible Spanish team.
My favorite part of it all is that I’ve watched countless people who typically couldn’t care less to watch any of those sports get completely swept up in the energy of these runs. Not because of the world-class athleticism on full display, but because of the stories underneath them. The sense that anything can happen, and that will and stubbornness can out-muscle pure talent when it matters most.
Some of my favorite songs tell stories that channel a similar ethos, and I asked the readers of Substack to share their favorite songs of grit and determination. Here are five of my favorites.
Check out the full crowdsourced playlist here:
“I Won’t Back Down” by Tom Petty
In May 1987, an arsonist broke into Tom Petty’s Encino home, doused the back staircase in lighter fluid, and set it on fire, while Petty, his wife, their young daughter, and their housekeeper were all still inside. Everyone escaped, but the house was gutted, causing roughly $1 million in damage. The only room left untouched was Petty’s basement recording studio. The arsonist was never caught.
For months afterward, Petty and his family shuttled between hotel rooms and a rented house, and he later admitted he could barely bring himself to use the word “fire” in a lyric. But on those long drives between temporary homes, he started writing what would become his first solo single. While “I Won’t Back Down” has become a sonic baby blanket for so many of us, Petty wrote it to comfort himself first.
“The Ballad of Ira Hayes” by Johnny Cash
Peter La Farge wrote this in 1962, and Johnny Cash’s 1964 recording turned it into one of the most devastating songs in the American songbook. It tells the true story of Ira Hayes, a member of the Pima tribe who enlisted in the Marines and became one of the six men photographed raising the flag on Mount Suribachi during the Battle of Iwo Jima — a battle in which only 27 of the 250 men in his unit walked back down the hill.
Hayes came home a national hero, paraded through ceremonies and handshakes. But back on the reservation, none of it translated into the dignity or support he’d earned. He struggled with alcoholism for the rest of his life and died just 10 years after the war, at 32. It’s the one story on this list with no comeback — the fight ended, and Hayes spent what was left of his life still living with what it cost him.
“Graceland” by Paul Simon
By the mid-1980s, Paul Simon was in what he later called a personal and professional “tailspin.” His marriage to Carrie Fisher had collapsed after a famously turbulent relationship, his creative partnership with Art Garfunkel had soured again, and his prior album had landed with a thud. Somewhere in the middle of that, he discovered a bootleg cassette of South African mbaqanga music, sparking an entirely new sound for him.
The trip that followed — first into that music, then to Johannesburg to record with the musicians who made it — became the album Graceland. The title track follows a father and son driving to Elvis Presley’s Memphis mansion, and Simon has said the song essentially wrote itself once he let Graceland become a metaphor instead of just a destination: a place, real or imagined, where broken things are made whole again.
“The Mary Ellen Carter” by Stan Rogers
Stan Rogers wrote this 1979 folk song about a fictional crew salvaging their sunken ship off the Canadian coast, refusing to let her stay on the bottom. It was always meant as something like a hymn for people who don’t believe in hymns. A promise that no matter what you’ve lost, you can rise again.
The song’s most remarkable moment happened years after Rogers wrote it, and after his own death in a 1983 plane fire. In February 1983, chief mate Robert Cusick was trapped aboard the cargo ship Marine Electric as it capsized in a violent Atlantic storm. Alone in a swamped lifeboat, freezing, and slipping toward hypothermia, Cusick has said the song’s final chorus came into his head, and he repeated it until rescue arrived. He later credited it with keeping him alive. Haunting to think Rogers never knew.
“El Paso” by Marty Robbins
This one has to be my favorite submission, and not just because of my lifelong love affair with the Grateful Dead who famously performed it live for decades.
Robbins wrote it in 1959 after driving across the Rio Grande from Juárez to El Paso on a Christmas trip home to Phoenix, and named its central character Felina after a childhood classmate. It became the first number-one song of the 1960s and won Robbins the first-ever Grammy awarded for country music.
The story itself is pure grit of a different, darker kind: a cowboy kills a rival over a woman in a cantina and flees on a stolen horse into the badlands of New Mexico.
Of course, he’s unable to stay away, and rides back into town to see Felina knowing full well it will get him killed.
Spoiler alert: Things don’t end so well for our horse-mounted hero.
Unlike the other songs on this list, it’s less “push through hardship and come out better” and more “refuse to stop at any cost.” But as a testament to sheer stubborn devotion, no other song does it better.
Go deeper: What’s your favorite song about grit? Let me know in the comments and check out the full crowdsourced playlist here: A Song For You: Grit.



Rise Up by Audra Day
Great list! Hot Water Music "Turnstile" would be a great add!