Sammy’s Thought Bubble: Victory on the Dirty Blvd.
A Song For You is proud to welcome guest author (and my dad!) Doug Criscitello to commemorate the Knicks’ long-awaited title run by diving into four tracks by the King of New York.
Growing up in a Knicks household, I constantly heard him tell stories about the dominance of the Clyde Frazier-led championship teams from the early '70s and the what-could-have-been Patrick Ewing-fronted squads of the '90s. Every story ended with him saying some version of “There’s nothing quite like New York City when the Knicks are winning”. To say he was right would be the understatement of the century.
In Their Own Words: Doug Criscitello Reflects on the Knicks’ Championship Run Through Four Lou Reed Songs
Yeah, I’m sure I could come up with something that rhymes with the faith of the mayor or my preferred breakfast carb, but let’s just leave it at this. Knicks in five.
But it was really game four that decided the series. You know the play. The Brunson three-point attempt hung in the air for what felt like 53 years. Then O(m)G. Knicks 107, Spurs 106. The largest comeback in NBA Finals history. MSG didn’t just erupt. The entire city and all of its expats exhaled after holding their collective breath for five decades.
Lou Reed, a lifelong Knicks fan, was definitely there in spirit.
I. I’m Waiting for the Man
Waiting for a player who would carry the Knicks to a championship was nothing like the casual waiting of a team hoping to get a high draft pick to help get them through a rebuilding cycle. It was deep, structural, intergenerational, painful, anxiety filled, and seemingly endless. A whole lot more like a nervous junkie looking to score.
The anticipation. The certainty that this time it’ll be different. The guy you’re waiting for who keeps not showing up. Then, when he finally does arrive, there’s hope for real potency, along with a willingness to try anything.
Bernard King was the man. Until his knee gave out in 1985, mid-ascent, taking with it what might have been the most unstoppable scoring season the league had ever seen.
Patrick Ewing was the man. For 15 years. Seven playoff runs. One Finals appearance, 1994, when he had it, when New York had it, almost. God, I loved those teams.
Carmelo Anthony was the man. He brought a national title to my long-suffering college team, the ‘Cuse, and we all hoped for a repeat in the NBA. Just didn’t work out.
Then, out of nowhere, he shows up. A whole lot smaller and slower than we had dreamed. Again, we’ll try anything.
II. Intro / Sweet Jane
If you’ve never heard the intro to Sweet Jane from the 1974 live album Rock n Roll Animal, stop reading and go listen to it now. Steve Hunter builds a guitar introduction that runs nearly three minutes, ascending in waves, the crowd already losing its mind before Lou Reed sings a single word. It is one of the great dramatic constructions in rock history. Pure anticipation in musical form.
Introducing Jalen Brunson.
He came from Dallas, where he’d been good but not indispensable. National champion in college — just like Carmelo. He signed with the Knicks in 2022 for money that seemed excessive at the time. He’s not physically imposing. He doesn’t dunk. He doesn’t have a signature move that makes arenas gasp. This is the man we’ve been waiting for?
He turns out to be exactly the man. Not the man the experts told us we needed. Not the man anyone would have written a scouting report predicting. But the guitar keeps building anyway, and when it finally resolves — when the whole band crashes in and the crowd reaches the pitch it’s been climbing toward — you realize the anticipation was always going to end here.
Brunson’s 45 points in Game 5 nearly matched the rest of the team. The clutch play down the stretch that gave New York a lead it never surrendered. The tears afterward, with his father, on the court in San Antonio.
III. NYC Man
But it wasn’t his championship alone.
OG Anunoby made the tip-in. Josh Hart dove on every loose ball like the floor owed him money. Mitchell Robinson grabbed the offensive rebound in Game 5 that sealed it. Karl-Anthony Towns, the gentle giant who’d waited for a moment like this his entire career, provided the size and skill that opened everything up. Mikal Bridges played like he wanted to get the city to rename the East River spans in his honor. Jose Alvarado brought a frenetic energy that reminded you basketball is supposed to be fun. And Miles McBride constantly had the crowd riled up with the “Deuce” chants.
NYC Man is Lou Reed at his most straightforwardly affectionate about the city he spent his career complicating. It is not ironic. It is not detached. It is just New York, the place, the people, the weight and joy of belonging to it.
The crowd shots from Game 4 tell the story. Not just at MSG — the bars, the streets, the firefighters leaning from their trucks to slap hands with strangers. The NYC expats across the country and around the world. A city that had been waiting longer than most of its current residents have been alive, finally getting the thing it had been promised and denied so many times that it had almost stopped believing.
This is New York’s championship. Brunson holds the trophy. The city shares it. Hell, the city earned it.
IV. Perfect Day
Lou Reed wrote Perfect Day as a quiet, almost unbearably tender song about a simple afternoon in the park. Sort of an emotional release — the moment after the long ordeal when you finally allow yourself to feel it.
The shot of Jalen Brunson with his father after the final buzzer in Game 5 is so fitting. Rick Brunson, former Knick, current assistant coach, has watched his son do something neither of them could have fully imagined when Jalen was a kid learning the game. They ended the wait.
Perfect Day is the right song for that. Not a triumphant song. Not a pump-up anthem. A song that understands that the best moments are also the most quietly devastating, that joy at this magnitude is indistinguishable from grief for everything it cost to get here.
The confetti will fall at the parade. The trophy will continue to gleam brightly. Somewhere in the East Village, in Coney Island, in neighborhoods Lou Reed walked through and wrote about and loved in his difficult way, people who waited their whole lives are watching this happen.
Unfortunately, Lou Reed passed away in 2013. I’m sure he would have had something dry and irreverent to say about the Knicks title. Or maybe he would have pretended not to care, channeling Bob Dylan’s recent remark that nothing surprises as you grow old.
But I have a feeling he would have been at the parade.
“New York City, ooohhh, how I love you.”





Lou would have been at the parade just like a Halloween Parade
Perfection, guys! I know writing this was truly cathartic. I’m hoping this post will get circulated to the many Knicks and/or Lou Reed fans as well as to anyone who simply loves to experience some amazing writing!