Welcome back to a very special edition of A Song For You.
Today we’re joined by one of the most magnificent voices in the Substack universe — Carrie Newcomer. A Grammy-acknowledged, Emmy-awarded artist, Carrie gives us a peek behind the curtain into her lived experience as a songwriter.
Carrie’s Substack, Gathering of Spirits, brings together a community of folks passionate about music, poetry, and art. Her writing offers a beacon of hope for how we can navigate difficult times with courage and compassion, and how art can help us find our way through.
She graciously took the time to chat about the power songs have to connect us — both to ourselves and to each other — and why that connection matters so much right now.
“How does the act of writing and composing a song compare to other art forms, like literature, film or visual art?”
Well, they’re all different animals, of course, and they all have their particular nuances. I’m a musician, but I’m also a poet, and I started out in visual art, and I feel like every art form has its wonderful and powerful components. There are things you can do in film that you can’t do in another medium. There are things you can do in an extended novel that are hard to do in any other way. But there is something about that wonderful little format of songwriting that always calls me back, that continues to fascinate me.
One of the things that makes songs and songwriting so powerful for me is that you have language, which is very powerful, but you also have music. The language, what you’re saying and the story you’re telling, and the music you’re using are completely entwined. Everything you’re saying in the language is backed up by what you’re saying musically, and vice versa. I often tell people that reading lyrics without the music is kind of like reading a novel and taking out all the verbs.
I also love that it’s condensed. Nobody but Bob Dylan gets 10-minute songs. Only Bob. Right? But for the rest of us, it’s short-form songwriting. In a song, every word matters and every note matters. If you lose your listener for one line because they’re trying to figure out who said what to who, you’ve lost them for several more lines, at least, while they parse together what just happened.
“How have the ways songs are written and received by listeners changed over the last 100 years, and what has stayed the same?”
Some things have stayed the same. A good song will move us to the heart. Something within a song vibrates on a personal level, and sometimes on a community level. When you think about songs that have been very important in movements for positive change in the last 100 years, there were songs that really helped people to rise up, to speak, to have a powerful voice in what they were trying to do.
I remember listening once to an interview with Vincent Harding, who was a very important activist and leader in the civil rights movement of the last century, and he was saying that we’re going to have “We Shall Overcome” forever. But in this interview, he also spoke about how we need the new songs. We need the songs that are coming, the voices that spoke to that moment.
After I listened to that interview, writing songs that you can sing along with became important for me. I write songs that people can sing, and they can sing together. Something really powerful happens when we sing together, and there are very few places where we do that anymore. I read in a scientific journal that when we sing together, our hearts sync up. When I heard that, it blew me away, and it made absolute sense too.
“For more than 20 years, my mother was a director of our local Music Together chapter, an early-childhood music program that I participated in as a kid. Seeing or performing live music often feels like an attempt to recreate those rooms as an adult. What does the communal experience of music mean to you?”
There are those who would diminish the power of music and what you experienced as a little child, but also what we experience all through our lives. I’ve heard people say, “Oh, it was just a kumbaya moment.” But most people have in their experience a time they remember when singing together and experiencing music together felt transformational, and transcendent in many ways. So when I hear those kinds of comments that are trying to diminish what happens when we experience music, as an individual or as a community, in ways that are really deeply moving and powerful, I just have to shake my head a little and say, “Well, you know, I’m not going there with you.”
“In this digitally fragmented world, maybe we need to be searching for more ‘kumbaya’ moments.”
Absolutely. There is nothing so powerful as an authentic song. Something that we’ve experienced as an individual, and then heard reflected to us in a song that came along exactly when I needed it. Or that came along for a community and was helpful, powerful, meaningful, and expressed something that we needed to say out loud as a community.
I’ve always said, as a songwriter, something really important in my songwriting happened when I gave myself permission to sound like a Hoosier. I’m from Indiana, I’m a Midwesterner, and I’m never going to sound like someone raised on the island of Manhattan, and that’s all right, because there are a lot of people to cover that voice. My most powerful voice will always be my truest voice, because we know it when we hear a song or a poem or a piece of art. When someone puts their finger on the pulse of something true, it shakes the world just a little bit. And why would I want to live any other way than true?
“To want to become a songwriter, you probably fell in love with other songwriters first. How did you avoid imitating your heroes and find your own voice?”
I was drawn to music because music moved me. There were artists that really moved me, and early on I was learning a lot of songs by those artists. We all have influences. We come from somewhere, and I have my influences, and most artists do. So part of that process was always, how does what I’m learning and what I love about this then come through my lens? How does it then speak through my voice?
I remember someone told me this great advice as a songwriter. He said, “Carrie, you know you don’t want to be the best singer-songwriter.” To which I said, “I don’t?” And he says, “No. You want to be the only Carrie Newcomer.”
It was such a wise and powerful thing to say to a young songwriter. Of course you learn, learn, learn. Musicians learn scales so that they can use all those notes, right? You learn lots of chords so you can use all those chords when you want to, and in the way that you want to. So you practice your craft, you develop your craft. But then the next step is, how do I speak through my own voice?
“Is there one song of yours that puts all of this together for you?”
As a songwriter, I have 21 albums trailing behind me now, and one of the things I like about having that body of work is that I never wrote a song because I had an answer. I write songs because I have a good question, and good questions continue to return, they deepen as I grow and evolve as a person. Sometimes, looking back over a body of work, I can see how I was writing myself into my next becoming. We’re always writing ourselves into our next becoming.
I have songs that I continue to sing because they continue to stay with me. One of those in my repertoire is a song called “You Can Do This Hard Thing.” It’s become a little bit of a signature song, but I continue to sing it not just because of that, but because it continues to unfold for me. It’s this idea of what is resilient in the human spirit, that against all odds will rise up, and also the importance of having those who will walk with you, particularly in difficult times, that we don’t always have to do this alone.
“Do the songs you write take on new seasons for you, or do you feel them more as a snapshot in time?”
Well, some of them don’t take on new seasons. And that’s really okay too. It’s like, that was a song for that moment, for that season of my life, and maybe someone else will sing it because it’s an appropriate song for this season in their life. I always say the nicest compliment you can ever give a songwriter is to sing the song and make it your own. So some songs do have seasons for me, and then some songs grow into what they are and grow with me, and there’s no real knowing if that’s going to be the case when a song is written. Sometimes I get an inkling of that, but not always. Sometimes it’s a surprise.
“Who is one songwriter you truly admire?”
John Prine. My husband is a music lawyer. When I met him, he was a full-time musician, and then he became my music lawyer and entertainment lawyer, and he works with some amazing musicians. He worked with John Prine before John passed, which was special because John’s songs were brilliant, first of all. They were just brilliant. But also, there was something so incredibly true about them on a human level. You can look at an audience at a John Prine concert and see people from all different walks of life, different ages, all singing along. It’s an amazing thing, and we’ll carry his songs with us forever.
At the heart of a good song, we recognize one another. In a time that seems so divisive and divided, when there are voices telling us there are divisions and there are no bridges, I don’t believe that’s true, because I experience the opposite happening all the time.
In songs, we see one another as human beings. Humans that have laughed and cried and grieved and been joyous and bewildered, everything that happens to us as human beings on a deep-down level. And I see that every time I go out on tour. People still see one another. We still encounter one another at the heart of a good song. And I think that’s so important right now, especially now, in a time that seems so broken and bewildering, that there are places where we still connect, that our hearts still beat as one. It happens all the time.
A Song For You: “You Can Do This Hard Thing” by Carrie Newcomer




In our neighborhood near Franklin Park in Boston we have gathered in groups of 3 to 23+ in the late afternoon/early evening to sing nearly every day since Covid hit. One of us sends out a song with a pdf of lyrics and a link to its recording and, weather depending, we sing on the sidewalk or in a living room with a portable speaker hanging off a pinky finger. It is not too much to say, I'd venture, that this community building and sustaining practice has saved folks' spirits and overall health. Kudos to you for your own part in keeping music in people's hearts as a buffer against the craziness and divisive nastiness of these times.
Music heals!
🙏
I am a huge fan of Carrie's poetry and her music (and her Substack Gathering of Spirits!). I completely agree about the power of music and singing together. When I think of singing in my life, I start of course with lullabies that I remember, then singing the standard toddler songs -- ABC, Twinkle Twinkle Little Star, Do You Know the Muffin Man, The Wheels on the Bus, etc., etc. And then came holiday music. Even if people weren't religious, many sang the holiday songs anyway because it brought them close together..."when we sing together, our hearts sync up." So true. Then summer camps, which I did as a camper every summer and then became a counselor. Songs were so important at the summer camps. There was a song for every occasion. When the sessions were over, there were tears for the friends we made and the experiences we had, but I truly believe that somewhere in there the real bond was that we were almost constantly singing together. I was a church-goer for 60 years. I think now (because I was never really comfortable with religion) that part of the "draw" for me was singing together. It's just so very important, significant, and powerful.
High school and college memories of the "greatest hits" that we sang together at parties, driving in the car, on the bus going somewhere. We all felt connected.
We are a musical family and we used to watch concerts together on PBS (and many live performances as well). Once I recorded Tchaikovsky's 100th birthday celebration when the entire 1812 Overture was played -- cannons, bells, and all. It was marvelous and it became a regular viewing experience for us, always with great anticipation and excitement. And Little Fugue in G Minor was the song we played as we were approaching our summer cottage. I had to make sure to start it just at the right time so that we arrived at the cottage at the same time the musical piece came to the frisson, the powerful climax. We had so much fun humming along with it, "conducting," and punching our fists in the air. Three of my four children are musicians, two of them professionally, and my husband has been a drummer since he was 6 and played in some excellent bands as a side career while working in the corporate world. Retired 3 years ago because of shoulder problems from all the drumming. Neighbors and friends went to many of his concerts and we had so much fun!!
I sang to my grandmother in her last weeks and days. She was the first one to sing "You Are My Sunshine" to me, and I sang it to her as she took her last breaths.
I'm not sure music has an equal. Many, many things in this world are special and important, but music is amazingly powerful and transformative.
Thank you for this wonderful conversation!